含羞草社区

?
?
English English
?

China Outbound Deals of the Year

China Outbound Deals of the Year

Chinese companies are increasingly expanding into overseas markets, enhancing their competitiveness and seeking new growth opportunities. In particular, President Xi Jinping’s visit to Latin America in November has brought this region back into the spotlight. As the China-Latin America strategic partnership deepens, countries such as Brazil, Argentina and Colombia have emerged as hotspots for Chinese investment.

In 2023, the value of trade between China and Latin America exceeded USD489 billion, an increase of nearly 15% year-on-year. Although China’s direct investment in the region has weakened in the past two years, the total stock of direct investment has grown nearly sevenfold compared to a decade ago.

In this promising landscape, M&A accounts for the majority of transactions. However, the complex legal ecosystems of Latin American countries pose significant challenges for foreign investors, leading to an increasing number of dispute resolution cases involving Chinese companies. As they expand into Latin America, Chinese enterprises must pay close attention to the local rule of law to ensure a secure presence.

In light of this, we have launched the China Outbound Deal Awards this year, with Latin America as the first focus region. The awards aim to recognise Chinese companies that have navigated this challenging market with skill. Successful transactions often entail viewing legal compliance as a strategic advantage rather than merely fulfilling contractual obligations.

In selecting the winners, we considered each project’s importance, complexity, innovation and size. After thorough research, we selected outstanding deals completed or significantly progressed between 1 March 2022 and 29 February 2024. No fees or other obligations were associated with the submission and judging process.

The Latin American region comprises more than 30 countries and territories, each with different economic and legal systems, levels of development and engagement with China, and varying transaction focuses and industries. Therefore, the list of winners is categorised by country, with deals or cases listed in alphabetical order of their English names rather than in any order of priority.

We hope this award will inspire more Chinese companies to write new chapters in the story of the vibrant Latin American market.

Argentina

Argentina

  1. CDB amends BICE’s financing rate
  2. CDB amends credit facility agreement again
  3. CRCCE, Plasser & Theurer tamping machines dispute
  4. Ganfeng Lithium buys Lithea
  5. Goldwind penalised for delays
  6. Goldwind’s wind power green loans
  7. Jinko Power buys Cordillera Solar
  8. MSU buys Chongqing Grain’s Argentina arm

ARGENTINA01

CDB amends BICE’s financing rate

CATEGORIES: Banking and financing

LEGAL COUNSEL: PAGBAM acted as the Argentinean counsel to the China Development Bank (CDB), while Zhong Lun Law Firm acted as the PRC counsel.

KEY POINTS: On 29 June 2023, CDB and Banco Industrial y de Comercio Exterior (BICE), Argentina’s second-largest policy bank, revised a USD150 million financing agreement originally signed in 2017. This amendment replaced certain risk-free interest rates with the London interbank offered rate as the benchmark for calculating interest payments, thereby improving interest rate risk management.

In this arrangement, CDB serves as the lender while BICE acts as the borrower. The amendment bolstered the credibility and stability of the interest rate benchmark, enabling both parties to price interest rates more accurately and mitigating the effects of future interest rate fluctuations on borrowing costs.

ARGENTINA02

CDB amends credit facility agreement again

CATEGORIES: Banking and financing

LEGAL COUNSEL: PAGBAM acted as the Argentinean counsel to the China Development Bank (CDB), while Zhong Lun Law Firm acted as the PRC counsel.

KEY POINTS: On 30 June 2023, CDB amended the USD2.1 billion credit agreement with the Argentine government and the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China for the fourth time. This amendment reset the London interbank offered rate as the benchmark interest rate for determining the interest payments under the agreement. This change will further support the rehabilitation of the Belgrano Cargas Railway project.

The rehabilitation plan is a key Chinese infrastructure initiative in Argentina, focusing on renovating 1,600 kilometres of railway. Its primary goal is to enhance the speed and stability of local freight trains. Once the renovation is completed, it is anticipated that freight volume will increase by 235% compared to previous levels.

ARGENTINA03

CRCCE, Plasser & Theurer tamping machines dispute

CATEGORIES: Dispute resolution; Automotive, industrial and manufacturing

LEGAL COUNSEL: Lenz & Staehelin and Global Law Office advised CRCC High-Tech Equipment Corporation (CRCCE), while Homburger acted for Plasser & Theurer.

KEY POINTS: The Austrian-based rail construction company, Plasser & Theurer, initiated commercial arbitration against CRCCE at the ICC arbitration court. The dispute centred on nearly 70 tamping machines exported to Argentina and India, governed by Swiss law, and involved intellectual property rights, breach of contract and market monopoly, with claims exceeding CHF20 million (USD22.6 million).

The arbitration concluded with a settlement, underscoring the challenges Chinese companies face when expanding globally, including navigating international legal frameworks and safeguarding technological innovations. This case also illustrates the growing interconnection between the Latin American market and global trade dynamics, as both firms seek to resolve their differences while preserving their competitive edge.

ARGENTINA04

Ganfeng Lithium buys Lithea

CATEGORIES: M&A; Lithium ore

LEGAL COUNSEL: Baker McKenzie FenXun has advised the buyer, GFL International, while Mayer Brown represented the seller, LSC Lithium.

KEY POINTS: GFL International, a wholly owned subsidiary of China’s largest lithium compounds producer, Ganfeng Lithium, acquired 100% of Argentina-focused Lithea for USD962 million from its parent company, LSC Lithium.

Lithea owns mining rights to two lithium salt lakes in Argentina, the largest proven lithium reserves in the world, with the biggest targeting annual lithium carbonate production of up to 50,000 tonnes. These mining rights will remain with Lithea.

Ganfeng Lithium said the transaction will shore up the company’s self-sufficiency in the key resource for electric vehicle battery manufacturing, and is in line with its EV industry development strategy. A blueprint for acquiring at least 300,000 tonnes of lithium carbonate before 2025 was announced by Ganfeng Lithium after the acquisition.

ARGENTINA05

Goldwind penalised for delays

CATEGORIES: Regulation; Energy

LEGAL COUNSEL: Martinez de Hoz & Rueda acted as the Argentinean counsel to Goldwind.

KEY POINTS: China’s wind turbine manufacturer, Goldwind, was fined about USD90 million by the Argentine Wholesale Electricity Market Clearing Company, the regulatory authority for the country’s electricity market, for not delivering a wind power project on schedule. Goldwind received a partial exemption from the fine, amounting to about 30% of the total.

The penalty stemmed from Goldwind’s failure to meet the project completion deadline outlined in the Power Purchase Agreement, which was associated with Resolution 202/2016 from the Argentine Ministry of Energy and Mining and the 1.5 round of the Intervention on Argentina’s Renewable Energy Auction (RenovAr) plan.

Since RenovAr’s launch in 2016, the plan has aimed to lower the cost of renewable energy by fostering competition and implementing mechanisms to ensure long-term price competitiveness. Goldwind was one of the major Chinese companies engaged in the plan during its early phases.

ARGENTINA06

Goldwind’s wind power green loans

CATEGORIES: Banking and financing; Energy

LEGAL COUNSEL: Bruchou & Funes de Rioja, Mayer Brown (the leading partners have now joined Haiwen & Partners) and Fangda Partners advised Goldwind on Argentinean, Hong Kong and PRC law, respectively. Bruchou & Funes de Rioja, Baker McKenzie and King & Wood Mallesons advised the syndicate of lenders on Argentinean, Hong Kong and PRC law, respectively. Tanoira Cassagne advised the agent, security agent, onshore security agent and onshore security trustee.

KEY POINTS: China’s wind turbine manufacturer, Goldwind, has signed a USD270 million green syndicated loan agreement with Banco Santander, China CITIC Bank International, and Bank of China for the Helios wind power project in Argentina. This marks the first instance of a Chinese company securing a green syndicated loan in US dollars tied to the secured overnight funding rate.

The transaction included share pledges, trust assignments of payment rights and receivables from the power purchase agreement between Goldwind and the Argentine Wholesale Electricity Market Clearing Company, Argentina’s electricity market regulator, and corporate guarantees. Additionally, it required compliance with the Central Bank of Argentina’s refinancing regulations and addressed various jurisdictional, governing laws and operational challenges related to timing and coordination.

Goldwind’s-wind-power-green-loans

ARGENTINA07

Jinko Power buys Cordillera Solar

CATEGORIES: M&A; Energy

LEGAL COUNSEL: Martinez de Hoz & Rueda acted as legal adviser to the buyer while Beccar Varela acted as legal adviser to the seller.

KEY POINTS: China’s photovoltaic giant Jinko Power has acquired 100% of the equity of Cordillera Solar, which was indirectly held by the buyer’s affiliate, Jinko Energy, for USD15.1 million. Cordillera Solar was part of the San Juan Solar Power Project, Argentina’s first large-scale solar power project and South America’s first megawatt-scale photovoltaic facility.

Despite repeated delays due to the pandemic and other factors, the transaction was successfully completed in June 2022. This acquisition eliminated competition between Jinko and its affiliates related to the San Juan power plant. The seller indicated that this deal aligns with the company’s global development strategy and will enhance its brand presence in Latin America.

ARGENTINA08

MSU buys Chongqing Grain’s Argentina arm

CATEGORIES: M&A

LEGAL COUNSEL: Barbosa Ugarte and Fangda Partners advised the buyer on Argentinean and PRC law, respectively.

KEY POINTS: One of Argentina’s largest agricultural companies, MSU, has acquired Oro Esperanza Agro, an Argentine firm controlled by Chongqing Grain Group, for USD19.5 million. The acquisition was completed through tender procedures within the Chongqing United Assets and Equity Exchange. The proceeds were used to address financial debts.

Chongqing Grain Group said its loss exceeded RMB5 billion (USD690 million) during the 12th Five-Year Plan due to heavy debt and unwise investments in Brazil, Argentina and other jurisdictions. To mitigate this crisis, the company publicly transferred many overseas assets via the exchange, which serves as a key platform for property rights trading in Chongqing, aimed at regulating the flow of state-owned assets.

Bolivia

Bolivia

  1. CITIC Guoan funds lithium plants
  2. Eximbank’s USD1bn public sector works

BOLIVIA01

CITIC Guoan funds lithium plants

CATEGORIES: Project; Lithium ore

LEGAL COUNSEL: Dentons acted as the Bolivian counsel to the Qinghai CITIC Guoan Technology Development, and Dacheng Law Offices acted as CITIC Guoan’s PRC counsel.

KEY POINTS: In June 2023, Chinese-owned company Qinghai CITIC Guoan Technology Development secured the bid for a lithium development project in Bolivia with an investment of USD857 million. The company collaborated with Yacimientos de Litio Bolivianos, a Bolivian state-owned enterprise, to establish a lithium carbonate production plant in Bolivia’s Salar de Uyuni (the world’s largest salt flat). The signing ceremony for the project was chaired by Bolivian President Luis Arce.

This project is of significant importance to Bolivia, especially as the country has faced challenges from the extraction and commercialisation of traditional natural resources such as oil, gas and gold in recent years. It represents a key initiative by the local government to sustain and revitalise the natural resources sector.

BOLIVIA01-CITIC-Guoan-funds-lithium-plants

BOLIVIA02

Eximbank’s USD1bn public sector works

CATEGORIES: Banking and finance; Infrastructure

LEGAL COUNSEL: Dentons acted as the Bolivian counsel to the Export-Import Bank of China (Eximbank).

KEY POINTS: Eximbank has provided USD1 billion of financial support for several key areas in Bolivian infrastructure and urban security. Since the borrower was a sovereign nation, it was necessary to address complex issues such as sovereign immunity.

The significant financings contributed to the El Espino-Charagua-Boyuibe highway project, the El Sillar highway project, and the public safety command and control system.

The El Espino-Charagua-Boyuibe highway project has built a corridor connecting Argentina and Paraguay, enhancing connectivity among the three countries. Meanwhile, the public safety command and control system has effectively reduced crime rates and ensured social stability and economic development in Bolivia.

Brazil

Brazil

  1. CanSino’s covid-19 vaccine exports
  2. CGN Brazil receives investment
  3. CGNP’s Brazilian solar project
  4. Chinatex sues Cotrijui for liquidation
  5. CNOOC ups Buzios oilfield stake
  6. Foton Motor’s distributor dispute
  7. Longsys buys Smart Brazil stake
  8. Risen Energy and Focus Futura settle

BRAZIL01

CanSino’s covid-19 vaccine exports

CATEGORIES: Trademark; Licensing; Medicine

LEGAL COUNSEL: Global Law Office acted as CanSino Biologics’ counsel.

KEY POINTS: CanSino vaccine, China’s first approved adenovirus vector-based covid-19 vaccine, has undergone clinical testing and production in several Latin American countries including Mexico, Chile and Argentina. CanSino Biologics is supporting many developing countries in Latin America localising vaccine production through technology transfer.

The export of this vaccine involved creating a co-operation model with various Latin American countries, drafting clinical trial agreements, and establishing product registration and supply arrangements. This process included extensive negotiations with multiple parties including global and local contract research organisations and researchers involved in the clinical trials.

BRAZIL02

CGN Brazil receives investment

CATEGORIES: Investment; M&A; Energy

LEGAL COUNSEL: Global Law Office acted as the project counsel to CGN Energy International Holdings, while Clifford Chance acted as international law counsel.

KEY POINTS: CGN Energy International has secured the China-LAC Industrial Co-operation Investment Fund as a strategic investor in its Brazilian subsidiary, CGN Brazil, raising RMB3.3 billion (USD455 million) through capital increases and share expansions.

CGN Brazil is a vital clean energy platform in South America, and the two parties plan to leverage this project as a foundation for further collaboration in countries along the Belt and Road Initiative.

Established in 2015, the China-LAC Industrial Co-operation Investment Fund is a government-backed investment fund focused on the Latin American region. With an initial capital of USD30 billion, the fund aims to foster partnerships between China’s leading industries and Latin American nations.

BRAZIL03

CGNP’s Brazilian solar project

CATEGORIES: Project; Energy

LEGAL COUNSEL: IW Melcheds acted for Energybras.

KEY POINTS: CGN Brazil, a subsidiary of China General Nuclear Power Group, is developing the Lagoinha Solar Complex in Ceará, marking the group’s first greenfield solar park in Latin America.

The project involves the acquisition of a 170MW solar complex from the renewable energy company, Energybras.

Once operational, the Lagoinha project is expected to generate 400 million kWh of electricity annually and reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 300,000 tonnes per year. This initiative underscores the positive impact that Chinese companies can have in advancing Brazil’s energy transition.

BRAZIL04

Chinatex sues Cotrijui for liquidation

CATEGORIES: Bankruptcy and liquidation; Dispute resolution

LEGAL COUNSEL: Souto Correa represented Chinatex, while Brizola e Japur acted as trustee.

KEY POINTS: After a decade of legal battles, Cotrijui, once the largest agricultural co-operative in Latin America, was ordered by a Brazilian court last year to enter judicial liquidation to settle more than BRL3 billion (USD505 million) in debts, including USD12 million owed to Chinatex.

Cotrijui’s financial troubles began in 2013, when it defaulted on soybean deliveries to Chinatex and failed to repay an advance payment. This situation led Chinatex to repeatedly petition a Brazilian court to seize Cotrijui’s assets.

In an attempt to avoid formal bankruptcy proceedings, Cotrijui sought out-of-court liquidation, resulting in Chinatex filing a lawsuit. The legal landscape shifted in 2019, culminating in the court’s final confirmation of Cotrijui’s judicial liquidation in 2023.

The case garnered significant media attention in Brazil, with Chinatex ultimately safeguarding creditor rights through various litigation efforts, independently and in collaboration with other creditors.

BRAZIL05

CNOOC ups Buzios oilfield stake

CATEGORIES: Investment; M&A; Petrochemicals

LEGAL COUNSEL: Tauil & Chequer and Mayer Brown advised China National Offshore Oil Corporation (CNOOC).

KEY POINTS: CNOOC has acquired a 5% stake in the Buzios oilfield, the world’s largest deepwater pre-salt oil producer, from Brazilian state-run oil firm Petrobras for BRL10.3 billion (USD1.73 billion). CNOOC became the largest partner of the oilfield’s operator, Petrobras, after the deal.

In 2019, CNOOC secured a 5% interest in the Buzios field, so with this latest purchase its total stake now stands at 10%. According to CNOOC’s 2022 figures, the Buzios oilfield produced 600,000 barrels of oil per day, making it one of the key drivers of growth for CNOOC’s overseas oil and gas production.

BRAZIL06

Foton Motor’s distributor dispute

CATEGORIES: Dispute resolution

LEGAL COUNSEL: Souto Correa represented Beiqi Foton Motor do Brasil and Foton Motor do Brasil Vendas. Mattos Filho represented Foton Aumark do Brasil (FAB).

KEY POINTS: In August 2023, a Brazilian court ruled in favour of Foton Motor in a contractual dispute with its Brazilian operational partner, FAB, regarding jurisdiction. This decision is a reference point for Chinese companies facing similar legal challenges.

In 2010, Foton Motor and FAB entered into several contracts allowing FAB to sell specific types of Foton vehicles in Brazil. While one contract lacked a dispute resolution clause, the others included arbitration provisions. In 2022, FAB’s judicial restructuring led to repeated delays in vehicle deliveries to Brazilian dealers, prompting Foton Motor to terminate its agreement with FAB and directly distribute vehicles to the dealers.

Subsequently, FAB sued Foton Motor for business “usurpation”, seeking compensation for BRL600 million (USD101 million). Foton Motor contended that the court lacked jurisdiction and raised various procedural and substantive defences. Ultimately, the Brazilian court recognised the validity of Foton’s defences and conferred exclusive jurisdiction to the arbitral tribunal, leading to the termination of the proceedings.

BRAZIL07

Longsys buys Smart Brazil stake

CATEGORIES: M&A; Semiconductors

LEGAL COUNSEL: Pinheiro Neto advised the buyer on Brazilian law, Zhong Lun Law Firm advised on PRC law, and Sidley Austin provided other international law advice. Latham & Watkins acted for the seller.

KEY POINTS: A-share listed company and memory manufacturer Longsys acquired an 81% stake in Smart Brazil for USD16.8 billion. While Chinese companies typically expand into the energy and infrastructure sectors, it is relatively rare for semiconductor storage firms to enter the Latin American market.

Smart Brazil was a leading manufacturer of memory chip packaging, testing and memory products in Brazil, boasting a well-established production base in the country. This acquisition has significantly enhanced Longsys’ overseas supply chain capabilities. The transaction involves multiple jurisdictions including China, the US, Brazil, South Korea and the Netherlands, resulting in a complex and lengthy legal process.

The target company was renamed Zilia Technologies after the merger.

BRAZIL08

Risen Energy and Focus Futura settle

CATEGORIES: Dispute resolution

LEGAL COUNSEL: Commerce & Finance Law Offices and Sidley Austin represented Risen Energy. Quinn Emanuel and Demarest represented Focus Futura.

KEY POINTS: China’s solar module manufacturer, Risen Energy, and Brazilian company Focus Futura entered arbitration proceedings at the ICC International Court of Arbitration in February 2023 over a contractual dispute. The two parties have now reached a comprehensive settlement.

In 2020, Focus Futura agreed to purchase 870 megawatts of photovoltaic modules from Risen Energy. However, a surge in global silicon prices led Risen Energy to seek a price renegotiation. Focus Futura then applied for arbitration and received a favourable ruling. Risen Energy later attempted to overturn this award in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York, but the court denied the request.

While the arbitration court supported Focus Futura, it ruled against claims that Risen had renegotiated in bad faith, stating that tough negotiation does not equate to bad faith and does not invalidate the contract’s limitation of liability clause.

Chile

Chile

  1. CPIH’s Punta Sierra energy storage project

CHILE01

CPIH’s Punta Sierra energy storage project

CATEGORIES: Banking and financing; Energy

LEGAL COUNSEL: Commerce & Finance Law Offices advised China Power International Holding (CPIH).

KEY POINTS: CPIH has invested USD2.3 million in the development and construction of the Punta Sierra energy storage project, which will support the Punta Sierra wind power project – the first South American wind farm funded by CPIH’s parent company, State Power Investment Corporation.

This energy storage initiative aligns with green energy goals and the ESG development concept, serving as a significant demonstration project. Energy storage plays a crucial role in Chile’s ambition to achieve carbon neutrality by 2050. Additionally, the established trading mechanisms within Chile’s electricity market offer both policy and market assurances for the successful commercial development of energy storage projects.

Columbia

Columbia

  1. Bogota Metro starts viaduct construction
  2. CRRC consortium wins Medellín project
  3. JCHX buys 50% of CMH
  4. Jiangling Motors’ antitrust dispute
  5. Vivo, DHL logistics dispute

COLUMBIA01

Bogota Metro starts viaduct construction

CATEGORIES: Infrastructure

LEGAL COUNSEL: Gómez-Pinzón advised Empresa Metro de Bogotá on Colombian law. Brigard Urrutia advised PLMB concessionaire on Colombian law.

KEY POINTS: In July 2023, construction officially began on the viaduct for Bogotá Metro Line One, the largest single project by a Chinese-funded enterprise in Latin America to enter full construction.

The Apca Transmimetro consortium, comprising China Harbor Engineering Company and Xi’an Metro Company, signed a USD5 billion contract five years ago for the design, construction, operation and maintenance of Bogotá Metro Line One. With a concession period of 28 years and three months, this project is the largest of its kind in Colombia to date. Empresa Metro Bogotá has contracted the PLMB concessionaire to oversee the construction.

The infrastructure initiative involves many complex legal challenges including line construction, concession agreements, land disputes and budgetary considerations.

COLUMBIA02

CRRC consortium wins Medellín project

CATEGORIES: Infrastructure

LEGAL COUNSEL: Gómez-Pinzón acted for CRRC (Hong Kong).

KEY POINTS: In October 2022, a consortium comprising CRCC (Hong Kong), Mota-Engil Engenharia e Constru?ao, Sucursal Colombia and Mota-Engil Colombia won the bid for the Metro80 light rail project in Medellín, Colombia, with a contract value of RMB3.7 billion (USD511 million). This new system will enhance Medellín’s existing rail network, which, until the completion of the Bogotá Metro, is the only urban railway in Colombia.

The project will establish a rail system featuring 17 stations along a 13-kilometre line, extending from Caribe in the north of Medellín to Aguacatala in the south.

COLUMBIA02-CRRC-consortium-wins-Medelli?n-project

COLUMBIA03

JCHX buys 50% of CMH

CATEGORIES: Equity investment; Mining

LEGAL COUNSEL: Gómez-Pinzón, McCarthy Tétrault, and Clifford Chance advised JCHX Mining Management on Colombian, Canadian and PRC law, respectively. Brigard Urrutia, and Cassels advised Cordoba Minerals on Colombian and Canadian law, respectively.

KEY POINTS: JCHX Mining Management has acquired a 50% stake in CMH, a wholly owned subsidiary of Canadian Cordoba Minerals, for USD100 million in a related-party transaction. On completion of the deal, JCHX Mining Management indirectly owned multiple CMH mining projects within the San Matias project in Colombia.

The San Matias project includes 100% of the Alacran copper-gold-silver deposits and satellite deposits at Montiel East, Montiel West and Costa Azul. Notably, the Alacran mine has been designated as a “project of national interest” by the Colombian government and is expected to become the largest copper mine in the country.

COLUMBIA04

Jiangling Motors’ antitrust dispute

CATEGORIES: Dispute resolution; Antitrust

LEGAL COUNSEL: Gamboa Garcia Roldan & Co represented Jiangling Motors.

KEY POINTS: Chinese commercial vehicle manufacturer Jiangling Motors has been involved in a complex antitrust lawsuit initiated by Soluciones Fullcar, a distributor in Paipa, Boyaca, Colombia. The case alleged that Soluciones Fullcar violated antitrust regulations by modifying its distribution agreement to favour local automotive company Comercializadora Andina de Automotores.

This case highlights the intricate relationship between contract law and antitrust regulations within the Colombian legal framework, emphasising the compliance challenges companies face in managing distribution agreements. The case is still under review, and its outcome could significantly impact how Chinese automotive companies manage distribution contracts in Latin America.

COLUMBIA05

Vivo, DHL logistics dispute

CATEGORIES: Dispute resolution; Electronic

LEGAL COUNSEL: Gamboa Garcia Roldan & Co acted for VV Technology, while Holland & Knight and Vivas & Uribe advised DHL.

KEY POINTS: VV Technology, the Colombian subsidiary of Chinese smartphone manufacturer Vivo, is suing international transport and logistics company DHL for breaching its obligations under a service agreement related to the storage and transport of smartphones in Colombia.

This litigation represents a significant milestone regarding the limitation of liability as stipulated in the agreement. The outcome could have far-reaching implications for the logistics and transport industry, as it may establish a crucial legal precedent concerning contractual liability in this rapidly growing sector.

Dominican Republic

Dominican Republic

  1. US ends investigation of Kingtom Aluminio

DOMINICAN REPUBLIC01

US ends investigation of Kingtom Aluminio

CATEGORIES: International trade

LEGAL COUNSEL: Dacheng Law Offices provided PRC law advice to Kingtom Aluminio, while Morris Manning & Martin acted as US counsel.

KEY POINTS: On 17 November 2023, the US International Trade Commission terminated its anti-dumping investigation into Dominican aluminium profiles following a protest from Kingtom Aluminio, a Chinese company based in the Dominican Republic. This marks the first time the commission has terminated a trade remedy investigation since the initial investigations began in 2009.

The current anti-dumping investigation involved aluminium profiles from 15 regions, with the Dominican Republic being the only country to receive a termination. The successful outcome of this case required a thorough analysis of industry damage data and a comprehensive understanding of US trade remedies and investigative priorities to formulate an effective response plan.

Ecuador

Ecuador

  1. Sinopec arbitration against Petroamazonas

ECUADOR01

Sinopec arbitration against Petroamazonas

CATEGORIES: Dispute resolution; Petrochemicals

LEGAL COUNSEL: Robalino and Claro & Cia advised Servicios Integrados Pa?aturi (Pa?aturi). Dechert represented Petroecuador.

KEY POINTS: On 12 May 2023, the Court of Appeals of Santiago rejected a petition from Ecuador’s state-owned oil company, Petroecuador, to annul a USD64 million international commercial arbitration award. This decision resolved a contractual dispute that has persisted for nearly four years with Pa?aturi, a subsidiary of Sinopec providing oil services, and reinforces the Chilean judiciary’s commitment to the principle of minimal interference.

The dispute originated in 2014 when Pa?aturi signed three service contracts with the former Petroamazonas, which merged with Petroecuador in 2020. The parties later disagreed on the calculation of service costs, leading Pa?aturi to file for arbitration in 2019, claiming that Petroecuador had failed to meet its payment obligations. An ad hoc arbitral tribunal based in Santiago, operating under UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules, ultimately ruled in favour of Pa?aturi.

Following the arbitration decision, the Attorney General’s Office of Ecuador appealed to the Court of Appeals of Santiago, which upheld the original ruling. In its judgment, the court emphasised that applications to annul international awards are extraordinary remedies, permissible only in cases of serious irregularities or significant violations of international public policy.

Mexico

Mexico

  1. Eximbank loan to China Power project
  2. Rainbow Agro, FMC pesticide IP case
  3. Saic Motor’s joint venture asset swap

MEXICO01

Eximbank loan to China Power project

CATEGORIES: Banking and finance

LEGAL COUNSEL: Commerce & Finance Law Offices acted for China Power International Holding.

KEY POINTS: China Power International has secured a USD100 million loan from the Export-Import Bank of China to acquire the Kinich photovoltaic project in Chihuahua, Mexico, marking the first cross-border renminbi loan issued by a Chinese bank in the Mexican power market.

This transaction is a key initiative under the Belt and Road Initiative and represents the first time China Power International has pursued a direct loan from a Chinese domestic bank for an overseas project.

The financing documents involved PRC, Hong Kong, English and Mexican laws, and adopted an innovative financing model that combines cross-border renminbi transactions with offshore currency swaps. This required a thorough review, amendment and negotiation of the International Swaps and Derivatives Association transaction documents for currency swaps during the project’s preparation phase.

MEXICO02

Rainbow Agro, FMC pesticide IP case

CATEGORIES: Dispute resolution; Intellectual property

LEGAL COUNSEL: Malpica Iturbe Buj & Paredes advised Rainbow Agro on Mexican law, while Finnegan acted as PRC counsel. Lazo Villa Moel y García advised FMC.

KEY POINTS: Mexico’s Industrial Property Specialised Chamber of the Federal Court of Administrative Justice issued a significant ruling against a patent infringement lawsuit filed by US chemical manufacturer FMC against Rainbow Agro, the largest pesticide exporter in China. This case underscores the critical importance of jurisdiction and valid patent claims in IP litigation.

Since May 2023, FMC has been pursuing legal action against Rainbow Agro, alleging that its products infringe patents 253292 and 265618. Initially, the court accepted FMC’s lawsuit and imposed precautionary measures restricting Rainbow Agro’s marketing activities. However, Rainbow Agro countered that FMC failed to provide sufficient evidence of actual product marketing, and that jurisdiction should lie with the Mexican Institute of Industrial Property.

Ultimately, the court ruled in favour of Rainbow Agro, determining that FMC’s claims were based on expired patents, and that the lawsuit had been improperly filed.

In response, FMC has filed an appeal with the Mexican Constitutional Court, seeking to overturn the ruling.

MEXICO03

Saic Motor’s joint venture asset swap

CATEGORIES: Joint ventures; Automotive

LEGAL COUNSEL: Dacheng Law Offices and Dentons advised SAIC Motor International.

KEY POINTS: SAIC Motor International, a subsidiary of SAIC responsible for import and export operations, has launched a new joint venture in Mexico. This initiative involved transferring assets, transactions, approvals and personnel from a local subsidiary previously joint owned by Anji Logistics USA.

While this project may seem like a straightforward establishment of a new entity, it signifies a substantial consolidation of SAIC’s overseas business operations. Anji Logistics USA Holdings has dissolved its former joint venture with SAIC Motor International, known as SAIC Motor México, and has formed a new joint venture, Saic Motor México, S de RL de CV, with SAIC Motor International. This strategic move aimed to streamline the approval process for overseas direct investment in China and minimise disruptions to local business activities.

Peru

Peru

  1. China Yangtze Power subsidiaries complete D/E swap
  2. CSG acquires Enel’s Peruvian assetss
  3. English, US courts sanction China Fishery’s restructuring

PERU01

China Yangtze Power subsidiaries complete D/E swap

CATEGORIES: M&A; Energy

LEGAL COUNSEL: Tian Yuan Law Firm advised China Yangtze Power and Yangtze Andes, while Estudio Muniz advised both on Peruvian law.

KEY POINTS: Yangtze Andes and Peruvian Opportunity Company (POC), China Yangtze Power’s subsidiaries in Hong Kong and Peru, respectively, completed a debt-to-equity swap of their shareholder loans. In particular, the swap amounted to USD3.36 billion for Yangtze Andes and USD470 million for POC.

The shareholder loans in question, provided by China Yangtze International (Hong Kong) and minority shareholders, respectively, were the primary funding source for Yangtze Andes’ earlier acquisition of Peruvian power distribution assets, as well as POC’s mandatory tender offer. The core asset of the acquisition was Luz del Sur, Peru’s largest publicly listed power company.

The acquisition occurred amid calls from former president Alan Garcia for a review of contracts with multinationals. The two subsidiaries successively entered into legal stability agreements with Peru’s Proinversion, which ensured stable income tax, foreign exchange supply, and exchange rates, as well as non-discriminatory treatment.

PERU02

CSG acquires Enel’s Peruvian assets

CATEGORIES: Tender offer; Outbound direct investment; Energy

LEGAL COUNSEL: Allen & Overy (now A&O Shearman) advised China Southern Power Grid (CSG), while Hogan Lovells advised Enel’s counsel.

KEY POINTS: CSG acquired Enel’s power distribution and supply business in Peru for USD2.9 billion. Enel, the world’s second-largest electric utility, sold an 83.15% equity stake in Enel Distribución Peru and complete ownership of Enel X Peru.

As Enel Distribución Peru was listed on the Lima Stock Exchange, the acquisition had to adhere to local requirements regarding tender offers. Additionally, the transaction was contingent on approval from the Peruvian antitrust authorities, and meeting China’s foreign direct investment regulations.

PERU02-CSG-acquires-Enel’s-Peruvian-assetss

PERU03

English, US courts sanction China Fishery’s restructuring

CATEGORIES: Bankruptcy restructuring

LEGAL COUNSEL: Miró Quesada & Miranda and Allen & Gledhill acted as the Peruvian and Singapore counsel to CFG Peru Investments (Singapore), respectively. Skadden acted as UK counsel to CFG Investment. Garrigues and CMS Grau advised Copeinca and CFG Investment on Peruvian law. Kirkland & Ellis and White & Case advised the ad hoc group on US law, while BlackOak acted as Singapore counsel. Philippi Prietocarrizosa Ferrero DU & Uría advised the creditor plan proponent.

KEY POINTS: China Fishery Group, once a leading global fishing company and owner of Copeinca, Peru’s largest fishmeal and fish oil producer, secured court approvals for its restructuring plan in London and the US in 2022 and 2023.

This initiative, involving its subsidiary, CFG Peru Investments (Singapore), and Peruvian arm CFG Investment, included debt-for-equity swaps, debt transfers, and the refinancing of USD450 million, alongside the creation of holding companies in Portugal and London. The plan encompasses multiple transactions such as corporate restructuring, stock purchase agreements and negotiations with creditors.

China Fishery Group faced significant challenges due to substantial debt. Its parent company, Pacific Andes International Holdings, filed for chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in New York in 2016, and the complex financial landscape had once hindered the progress of the global restructuring plan, which remains ongoing.

Suriname

Suriname

  1. Zijin buys Rosebel mine

SURINAME01

Zijin buys Rosebel mine

CATEGORIES: M&A; Mining

LEGAL COUNSEL: McCarthy Tétrault advised Zijin Mining, while Fasken advised Iamgold.

KEY POINTS: Zijin Mining acquired a 95% stake in Rosebel Gold Mines from Canadian company Iamgold for USD360 million, with the target company’s core asset being the Rosebel gold mine in Suriname. According to Zijin Mining, Rosebel Gold Mines represents about one-third of Suriname’s national gold production and ranks among the largest gold mines in South America.

The acquisition was finalised in February 2023. Before closing the deal, the transaction required approvals from several authorities, including China’s National Development and Reform Commission, the Ministry of Commerce and the Administration of Foreign Exchange. Additionally, the government of Suriname needed to approve the transfer of licences, and the board of directors of the target company had to resolve to approve the transaction, among other necessary documentation.

Global Law Office
Tian Yuan Law Firm-天元律师事务所-DOTY 2023
Zhong Lun Law Firm

Related article

Recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments, arbitral awards

By Lei Ting and Wu Ziyu, Global Law Office

Follow us on LinkedIn